Impact on Illinois' Structural Deficit

Impact on Illinois' Structural Deficit
Released

The state of Illinois faces a significant structural deficit into the future. The report highlights the nature of the structural deficit and identifies two key causes: the state’s historically flawed  tax policy and the plan devised for repayment of Illinois’ pension debt. CTBA proposes both the adoption of the Fair Tax and a reamortization of the pension debt as described in the report titled: Addressing Illinois’ Pension Debt Crisis With Reamortization. Doing so would allow the State to ensure full funding for the Evidence Based Funding Formula while also improving the status of Illinois’ public employee pension system and eliminating the State’s structural deficit by 2042.

Analysis of the FY2014 General Fund Budget

Analysis of the FY2014 General Fund Budget
Released

The fiscal problems that have historically plagued Illinois are on full display in the FY2014 General Fund budget passedby the Illinois General Assembly. The state’s accumulated deficit remains significant, and in all likelihood will be at least $8 billion by the end of FY2014. Despite increases for some aspects of the General Fund budget, net spending on services will be $173 million less in FY2014 than in FY2013. Meanwhile, as spending on service delivery continues to decline, the annual cost of debt service continues to grow—specifically the debt owed to the state’s five public pension systems. 

All of these problems can be traced back to the state’s flawed tax policy, which creates inadequate revenue growth to maintain service levels from one year to the next. This means that, even when spending on services are held constant in real, inflation-adjusted terms over time, deficits nonetheless materialize due to insufficient revenue growth. This makes it incredibly difficult for Illinois to provide public services at the levels needed to meet the demographic needs of the state. But as difficult as things are now, given current law on state tax policy, they are about to get much worse. 

That is because the temporary income tax increases passed as part of the Taxpayer Accountability and Budget Stabilization Act of 2011 (PA 96-1496)1 will begin to phase out in fiscal years 2015 and 2016. Unfortunately for Illinois, the additional revenue being generated from those temporary tax increases are all that stand between state government and insolvency. Consider that the accumulated deficit projected for the FY2014 General Fund will be at least $8 billion, even with the revenue from the temporary tax increase. That means 32.5 percent of the $24.5 billion in scheduled spending on services for FY2014 is in reality deficit spending. If Illinois did not have the revenue from the 2011 temporary tax increases over the last three fiscal years, and spending were held constant, the state’s accumulated deficit in FY2014 would be $33 billion—meaning the deficit would be $8.5 billion more than total service appropriations.

For too long, Illinois has tried to resolve its structural fiscal problems with temporary fixes, service cuts and irresponsible practices—like borrowing against the pensions. All, predictably, to no avail. The FY2014 General Fund budget makes it abundantly clear that the time for half measures has passed. To solve its structural problems Illinois must enact comprehensive tax reform that simultaneously: (i) generates adequate new revenue to sustain investments in core services over time; (ii) taxes citizens more fairly; and (iii) otherwise comports with the principles of sound taxation for a modern economy.

Cook County's Revenue System is Structurally Unable to Support the Public Services it Provides

Cook County's Revenue System is Structurally Unable to Support the Public Services it Provides
Released

Local governments, such as counties, cities, and townships, provide a number of basic public services that help create safe, clean, healthy, vibrant communities. Cook County, which has over five million residents and is the second largest county in the nation, is no exception. It delivers such essential services as public safety, the operation of the largest court system in the United States, health care for poor and low-income individuals through three public hospitals and 14 community clinics, the operation of the largest jail facility in the nation, and economic and human development programs. The cost of the public services Cook County will provide in FY2007 is $2.8 billion. By comparison, the annual budget for Los Angles County, which has nearly 10 million residents, is over $21 billion annually.

This Report analyzes the County’s fiscal system to determine whether it has the ability to fund and sustain the level of public services it currently provides. The analysis reveals Cook County has what is called a “structural deficit.” A structural deficit exists when a public entity’s fiscal system is unable to generate sufficient revenue to support base-level public services from one year to the next, adjusting solely for annual inflationary costs. It is important to recognize that the model used in this report assumes service levels will remain constant – that is, when running simulations of the cost of public services into the future, no service expansions are projected from FY2007 levels. Therefore, the starting point for the analysis in this Report is the service levels existing after the cuts made in FY2007.

Illinois Burgeoning Unfunded Liability, More Than a Pension Problem!

Illinois Burgeoning Unfunded Liability, More Than a Pension Problem!
Released

The three primary sources of contributions which finance Illinois state retirement systems are employee contributions, employer (the state) contributions and investment returns. According to the most recent state comparison of unfunded pension liabilities by Wilshire Research Associates, at $40.7 billion, Illinois has the worst unfunded pension liability in the nation. Moreover, when compared to Illinois FY06 total general revenue fund of $28.65 billion, Illinois $40.7 billion dollar unfunded liability represents 142% of FY2006 total general fund. This Report explains the source of Illinois immense unfunded liability, and how it relates to the state's budget and overall fiscal position.

Testimony to the Pension Modernization Task Force, Funding Subcommittee

Testimony to the Pension Modernization Task Force, Funding Subcommittee
Released

CTBA's August 2009, testimony to the Pension Modernization Task Force, Funding Subcommittee.

CTBA's Testimony and Presentation to the Pension Conference Committee

CTBA's Testimony and Presentation to the Pension Conference Committee
Released

The Illinois Pension Conference Committee, the 10-member legislative group charged with forging a compromise solution to pension problems, held its second hearing on July 3, 2013. At that hearing CTBA's Executive Director Ralph Martire testified on CTBA's proposed solution to amortize the debt owed to the retirement systems (the unfunded liabilities) to create a feasible repayment schedule.

"For Each and Every Child"

"For Each and Every Child"
Released

Ralph Martire's presentation on national education reform and the the federal Equity and Excellence Commission's report presented at the National Conference of State Legislators in Atlanta, GA. The federal Equity and Excellence Commission was asked to examine disparities in meaningful educational opportunities that give rise to the achievement gap, with a focus on systems of finance, and provide recommendations on which federal policies could address such disparities. The Center for Tax and Budget Accountability's Executive Director, Ralph Martire, served as one of the 27 commissioners.

The Impact of State Budget Shortfalls on Payments to Medicaid Health Care Providers

The Impact of State Budget Shortfalls on Payments to Medicaid Health Care Providers
Released

A Fact Sheet on impact of state budget shortfalls on payments to Medicaid healthcare providers in Illinois.

Proposed Federal Cuts Threaten Illinois' Medicaid Program

Proposed Federal Cuts Threaten Illinois' Medicaid Program
Released

This Report provides information on how proposed federal cuts to Medicaid in 2006 would have affected Illinois' program.